giochi online gratis casino slot machine wild stars slotzilla las vegas discount sizzling 7 slot machine game online
best online casino no rules bonus spirit mountain casino online slots best ipad black friday 2018 corporate casino night invitations slot machine cake ideas super casino bonus
best android mobile under 20000 ndtv casino games welcome bonus faraon casino online
casinos in lake charles la reviews roulette killer mansion casino bonus code
slot machine online gratis senza soldi read russian roulette online pdf casino slots bonus wins best online casino mac bonus gratuit sur casino en ligne qt creator signal slot tutorial mobile deals on black friday uk
make money from home fast and easy big cash casino bad zwischenahn games com crazy monkey
casino do estoril online make money online - passive income masterclass casino el camino food network roulette online gambling online casino no deposit bonus canada online casino 7
best desktop deals black friday 2018 motels near ameristar casino kansas city slot machine android games online casino games with no minimum deposit
vera and john casino mobile make quick money now online novomatic slots list black friday sales canada 2018 apple best buy black friday 2018 4k tv
coral cash how can i make money online instantly

03 December 2012

Response to Bartky: Foucauldian Discipline and the Intersectionalities of Sexism, Gender Binarism and Cissexism, and Heterosexism

table for 7 year old bally hot shot slots online casino jobs miami fl metodo per vincere alla roulette online
This is a brief response paper I wrote for my Introduction to Philosophy class. Not likely my best work, but it earned an A! Thought it might be of interest to you all lovely folks.

__________
betonline transfer to poker scr casino online scatter slots tips and tricks

royal casino panda live online roulette software way to make good money online online blackjack for money best sites mobil chevrolet spin baru open turnkey online casino
Bartky draws on the Foucauldian idea of docile bodies subjected by systems of power and discipline to self-regulation in order to understand the systemic and societal oppression of women by the patriarchy. The feminine subject, like the inmate in the Panopticon who becomes by virtue of the prison's structure his own jailer, polices herself according to standards of femininity (Bartky 79). Bartky's argument for the strict litany of standards of femininity in a woman’s physical appearance, body language and behavior, and conception of her self maintains that these standards and a woman’s rigid adherence to them are perpetuated by a system that enforces patriarchal power on the feminine subject. As Bartky argues, internalized oppression is the result of women believing that the norms demanded by patriarchy ought to be applied to themselves, and understanding themselves within the context of patriarchy (Bartky 77).

She briefly addresses the intersectionality between sexism and heterosexism in her observation that "[the categories of masculinity and femininity] may account to some degree for the otherwise puzzling phenomenon of homophobia," but does not present an adequate understanding of the nuanced complexities undergirding the relationships among sexism (as enforced by the patriarchy), heterosexism, and gender binarism (Bartky 77). Bartky grants that "persons currently can be only as male or female," but does not expand her argument of patriarchal power as a disciplinary power to any understanding of gender binarism and cissexism (Bartky 77). (The patriarchy-derived constructions of masculinity and femininity must by definition contribute to gender binarism, and thus cissexism, and to standards of heteronormativity, which provides the foundation for a profoundly heterosexist society. These three forms of oppression are inextricably interwoven, as the intersectionalities among them exist both among the oppressed groups of women, the non-cisgendered, and the queer, and among the analogously privileged groups of men, the cisgendered, and the heterosexual.) For its limited scope, however, Bartky’s argument of patriarchal power as applied solely within the gender binary provides an excellent example of the ways in which hierarchies of oppression are reinforced by systemically embedded praxes of disciplinary power.

Foucault argues that the "ideal point of penalty today would be an indefinite discipline...a procedure that would be at the same time the permanent measure of a gap in relation to an inaccessible norm and the asymptotic movement that strives to meet in infinity" (Panopticon). From Bartky's argument, we see that the indefinite discipline of the construction of femininity lies in the constant subjugation of women to societal messages that reinforce and uphold the ideals of the patriarchy that separate standards of appearance, behavior, and mannerism into those acceptable for the masculine and those required for the feminine, and in the internalization of these profoundly sexist ideals by women who strive to embed them into their own daily practices and behavior. Disciplinary power is one that seeks not to punish but to shape and structure (Panopticon). In the context of socially-embedded sexism, the power attributed to the patriarchy—the system that privileges and empowers men while simultaneously disempowering, disenfranchising, and oppressing women—is one that disciplines women into constricted constructions of femininity while conditioning those same women to self-discipline and enforce upon themselves the same sexist ideals.

As Bartky argues that constructions of masculinity and femininity go beyond “the construction of personal identities” to become “critical elements in our informal social ontology,” she advances the idea that construction of identity is a fundamental aspect of construction of society. Individual and social contributions to these constructions form the hierarchies of power and privilege that oppress and marginalize, subjecting members of society to external modes of disciplinary power that enforce a sense of normativity centered on the experiences and perceptions of privileged groups. It is impossible to challenge these norms and systemic oppressions without understanding the nature and function of their power to impose on those marginalized by them. Bartky’s argument for a Foucauldian understanding provides the basis for grasping the disciplinary power exerted by those who oppress on those whom they oppress in melding a society that fits a paradigm built around the identities and norms of those with such power and privilege. This disciplinary power is essential to maintaining the status quo, and while those who are oppressed participate as self-enforces of their own oppression, social structures like the patriarchy will remain in place.


__________
Works Cited
casino boats in clearwater florida instant casino m casino las vegas entertainment aku isterinya slot akasia online bingo flash online casino casino essentials active shooter training
Bartky, S. “Foucault, Femininity, and the Modernization of Patriarchal Power” t mobile black friday 2018 promotions roulette yeezy

Foucault, M. “Panopticism”. Discipline and Punish. Available at http://foucault.info/documents/disciplineAndPunish/foucault.disciplineAndPunish.panOpticism.html

5 comments:

  1. Bravo! Very well written response!

    ReplyDelete
  2. snoqualmie casino ballroom capacity online roulette real money no deposit microgaming casino no deposit bonus codes mansion casino mobile online roulette malaysia

    I'd give that an A for sure. :-)

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi. I'm not sure where your contact info is, so I'll leave a comment here. I've noticed that many things you write use "he or she" rather than gender-neutral pronouns. As a genderqueer Autistic, I'm frustrated when gendered pronouns are used when a simple "they" could suffice. I feel like I shouldn't have to make this comment, either, considering your extensive knowledge on exclusive language. I just thought I should point that out to you. Great posts, though.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. slot machine online gallina best online casinos new zealand casino near wetumpka al
      Lydia BrownDecember 16, 2013 at 2:07 AMpasarea spin film online casino no deposit bonus uk bonus casino extreme live casino jackpotcity casino flash casino no deposit bonus usa

      Sorry, I just remembered that this comment was here -- I am continually learning and trying to do better. A lot of the posts on this site, especially older ones, are evidence that how I think and understand myself and others, and the violence of our societies, has changed. Sometimes when I find specific posts that contain language that doesn't gel with me anymore, I edit it. Other times, I feel that maybe that would be intellectually dishonest, because at the time I wrote something problematic, I meant it the way it was written. That doesn't excuse past mistakes, but I don't want to try to alter the record either as if I didn't make them. On the other hand, if there are specific places where you think the language should definitely be changed (perhaps because it is unacceptable to leave it up?) please let me know. I'm open to doing that.

      Delete
    livermore casino commercial play casino games win real money casino online slot games rock casino tampa florida online slot machines with bonus games lucky creek casino no deposit bonus codes
  4. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
Load more...casino us players casino philadelphia stadium online gambling sites that accept credit cards pokemon fire red how to win slots email marketing for small business online real money gambling sites us mobile network market share
best gaming laptop black friday 2018 gala games any casinos near panama city beach florida casino sites that accept paysafe casinos in hawaii onlinecasino co

If you are having difficulty commenting, try using the Name/URL option instead to avoid logging into any third-party service.

best ac casino slots lake palace casino bonus codes 2018 monte carlo casino baccarat massena internet casino franchise
black friday 2018 uk ps4 price utah casino company new no deposit online casino bonuses online kajot automat casino
21 nova casino mobile gambling games examples yebo no deposit bonus codes cash online slots live roulette review silver oaks casino bonus how can i make extra money online
slots and casino games new rival casino no deposit bonus codes cajot online casino no deposit casino bonus 2018 netent wind creek casino slots roulette 3 number bet
payroll software for small business mac mobile online roulette no deposit bonus real money casino baccarat zodiac paperweight star vegas casino online
star trek online spin the wheel quest rta online slot booking gambling $50 casino bonuses list mechwarrior online mech slots casino online 1 cent casino red slots